10 Maple Extract Substitutes (Rum?!)

Maple extract substitute

Need a maple extract substitute? Maple extract can be substituted with several options, some of them including maple syrup, vanilla extract, almond extract, rum, etc. All of these options have the same sweet maple flavor, which means you can use them as substitutes for one another.

Pure maple extract is a popular flavoring made of evaporated maple tree sap. It is used to make maple frosting, glaze, and other desserts. Keep reading to learn more about maple extract substitutes!

Maple Extract Substitute

Here is the list of best maple extract substitutes:

Maple extract substitute pin

1. Maple syrup

Maple extract and maple syrup have the same taste, but if you plan to use pure maple syrup instead of maple extract, be aware of the ingredient ratio.

For every teaspoon of maple extract, you should use 1/2 – 3/4 teaspoons of maple syrup.

Maple syrup has a thicker consistency and a natural sweetness that makes it great to put on your ice cream, fruit salad, or other desserts. It is a healthier alternative to maple extract.

2. Maple sugar

Maple sugar has the same flavor as maple extract, only a bit milder.

It is perfect when you want your dessert to be sweet but without too much maple flavor, which can be overpowering sometimes. Replace 1 teaspoon of maple extract with 1 teaspoon of maple sugar.

3. Maple butter

Another excellent substitute for maple extract, maple butter has a rich flavor, stronger than maple extract.

That’s why you should replace 1 teaspoon of maple extract with only 1/2 teaspoon of maple butter.

4. Maple candy

Another option to use in place of maple extract. Maple candy is made of pure maple syrup with a hard center. 1/2 cup of maple candy will be enough to replace 1 cup of maple extract.

Keep in mind that you will need to melt the maple candy slowly to use it instead of maple extract.

5. Maple pecan flavored extract

Also a great option to use instead of maple extract.

It has a familiar taste of maple extract but with a nutty flavor. It is best used in drinks and desserts.

6. Maple-flavored coffee creamer

Maybe not the perfect substitute for maple extract, but it will still bring a warm flavor of maple syrup or extract to your desserts.

However, you will need to use 2 cups of maple-flavored coffee creamer to substitute 1 cup of maple extract.

7. Molasses

If you need something that will bring a sweet taste to your dessert, molasses can replace maple extract. Be aware that molasses has a strong dark sugar flavor, which is different than a sweet maple flavor.

8. Vanilla extract

Another substitute for maple extract, 1/4 cup of vanilla extract can replace 1 cup of maple syrup or maple extract.

9. Almond extract

Although it won’t give you that robust flavor of maple extract, almond extract can still be used as a maple extract alternative. It has a similar flavor to vanilla but with a deeper tone. 1/4 teaspoon of almond extract will be enough to replace 1 teaspoon of maple extract.

10. Rum extract

This extract is popular when making cakes, cookie doughs, cocktails, and desserts, but you can also use it instead of maple extract. Use as much rum extract as you would use maple extract.

Maple Extract Substitute Maple Syrup

Maple liquid extract is a good maple syrup substitute and vice versa. Maple syrup is sweeter than maple extract, so keep that in mind when using them to replace each other.

Maple Syrup Vanilla Extract Substitute

Although they have different flavor profiles, maple and vanilla extracts can be used to replace each other. Don’t forget that vanilla extract is much stronger, and you can use it instead of maple extract in a ratio of 1/4: 1.

What Can Be Substituted For Maple Extract

There are plenty of options when replacing maple extract, and you can use maple extract as their substitute too. This means that you can use maple extract instead of maple syrup, maple sugar, maple butter, vanilla extract, almond extract, rum extract, and so on.

Can I Substitute Maple Extract For Maple Flavoring

Maple extract is one of the most used maple flavorings. There are other maple flavorings like maple syrup, maple sugar, maple candy, and maple butter. You can substitute maple extract for each of these maple flavorings.

Can You Substitute Maple Syrup For Extract?

You can use maple extract instead of maple syrup, but keep in mind that maple extract has a weaker maple flavor, which means that you will need to use more of it to achieve the same flavor as maple syrup.

Can You Make Maple Extract?

Maple extract is usually made of evaporated sap of maple trees, but you can make your own maple extract. The main ingredients are 1 cup of pure maple syrup and 1 cup of vodka or other high-proof liquor. Combine the ingredients and let them sit in your fridge for at least 3 days.

How Do You Mimic Maple Flavor?

Apart from using maple flavorings, you can mimic maple flavor with honey, molasses, agave nectar, or corn syrup. Another alternative is using a birch tree syrup, which is similar in taste to the maple syrup.


Now you know your best options for a good maple extract substitute. Maple syrup, maple sugar, maple butter, and maple candy are all great choices for when you want the exact substitute.

However, you can also use vanilla extract, almond extract, or rum extract when you want to achieve a sweet flavor similar to the maple extract.

You can also make your own maple extract using maple syrup and vodka or other high-grade liquor.

Share this post, it will help me a lot!

Leave a Reply